Skip to content

News5 min read

N.B.’s Bill 12 Would Make Platforms Answer for Purchase Traps Aimed at Kids

Reported and fact-checked by NB Tech News staff; drafted with AI assistance. How we use AI

The proposal targets deceptive countdowns, purchase pressure and manipulative defaults for under-16s, with cancellation rights and a burden of proof on providers. It is not law.

A hypothetical game purchase screen with a deceptive countdown, followed by a proposed cancellation notice and Bill 12 marked not yet law; no real platform is accused.

A game that uses a false countdown to hurry a child into buying, or a platform that makes it difficult to stop using its service, could face more than a complaint under New Brunswick’s Bill 12. The proposal would give under-16s and their parents a route to cancel agreements affected by unfair practices — and put the onus on a provider to prove it did not engage in an alleged unfair practice.

The legislature’s bill record shows Bill 12, formally titled An Act Respecting Young Persons, Digital Markets and Technology Use, was introduced November 3 and passed second reading November 6. As of November 7, it is not law. Its proposed consumer-protection regime would come into force on a date or dates set by proclamation.

The strongest part of the proposal is not an age ban. It is an attempt to make the design of digital purchasing and engagement itself accountable.

What would count as an unfair practice?

Bill 12 would create the Young Consumers in Digital Markets Act, administered by the Financial and Consumer Services Commission of New Brunswick. Its full text covers more than completed purchases: a “consumer interaction” includes advertising, recommendations, promotion and use of a digital product or platform.

Section 7’s proposed prohibitions include:

  • Deceptive purchase design: interfaces that encourage a purchase or charge through deception or undue influence.
  • False urgency: rewards, scarcity messages, countdowns, streaks or rankings that create a false, misleading or unreasonable sense of urgency or scarcity to induce spending.
  • Getting stuck: services designed to discourage or impede a young consumer from disengaging, stopping or pausing use.
  • Misleading defaults: settings that are deceptive or excessively one-sided in the provider’s favour.
  • Targeted pressure: profiling or behavioural-data advertising that is false or misleading or intended to improperly influence purchasing decisions.

Not every timer, streak or personalized ad would automatically be unlawful. The wording attaches conditions to those practices. Another provision would restrict engagement notifications during hours still to be prescribed; the bill itself does not set a bedtime.

Section 10 says an unfair practice can occur even without a purchase, a direct contract with the affected child or a financial loss. That gives the proposal a wider reach than refunding accidental game spending.

Platforms would have to answer the allegation

The proposed act applies to providers that target young consumers or know or ought reasonably to know that under-16s use, or are likely to use, their products. It is not limited to apps explicitly marketed as children’s products. Exemptions could be set by regulation or granted by the director.

Section 8(3) says that when a provider is alleged to have engaged in an unfair practice, the provider bears the onus of proving it did not. The overall impression of a practice can be considered, not just the literal wording in a button or agreement.

The definitions explicitly include virtual items, digital skins, games, streaming, social media and AI services. That last phrase does not make this a special ban on children buying AI. AI is one category of digital service covered by the broader rules. The tabled text does not impose an express universal age-verification requirement.

A business website used as a storefront for physical products is excluded from the definition of “digital platform.” That is a specific definition, not a blanket declaration that every online retail interaction is outside consumer law.

What a family could do about a charge

Under proposed sections 11–17, parents and guardians would be included in the cancellation and recovery provisions. If an unfair practice affected an agreement, the young consumer could cancel it without cost or penalty.

Notice would generally have to be given within one year of entering the agreement, with the intention to cancel or seek recovery and the reasons for doing so. Email is an expressly permitted method. The provider would have to refund all consideration paid under the cancelled agreement and related agreements within 15 days of cancellation. Future authorized payments would also have to stop.

This would not be a general one-year no-questions-asked refund policy. The cancellation right depends on an unfair practice. If cancellation or restitution is no longer possible, the bill instead provides for recovery of the amount paid above the value received, damages, or both.

The proposal also provides a court route for harm or loss caused by unfair practices, including Small Claims Court within its jurisdiction. Notice requirements, response periods and some cancellation details are left to regulations. These are proposed rights, not a new refund process families can invoke today.

Three different penalty routes — not one automatic $5-million fine

The bill separates administrative enforcement from prosecution:

  • An administrative penalty officer could issue a notice carrying up to $10,000 for an individual or $25,000 for a non-individual under section 26.
  • After a hearing, the tribunal could impose an administrative penalty of up to $1 million under section 50. It could not use that route for a contravention already covered by an officer’s penalty notice.
  • Conviction for offences under section 45 could bring up to $5 million, up to five years less a day in prison, or both. That is a prosecution provision, not the routine price of receiving a complaint.

The tribunal could also order changes in business practices or cessation of regulated activities. Proposed protections would prevent providers from contracting out of the act’s rights, and would prohibit agreement terms forcing disputes into courts outside NB or choosing governing law other than NB or Canadian law.

The difficult part is enforcement

Justice Minister Rob McKee told CBC the legislation would apply even to companies without a Canadian office. That is the government’s position on its intended reach, not proof that an overseas platform will comply or that every jurisdictional dispute is settled.

CBC also reports no additional provincial funding accompanies the proposed responsibility. McKee argues the commission’s existing finances would support hiring and training. Green MLA Megan Mitton questioned whether it would have enough resources to regulate large companies. FCNB says it is funded by fees and assessments from regulated sectors, rather than provincial funding.

The text supplies investigation, court and tribunal powers. It does not establish how quickly families would get results from a global company contesting a case.

Bill 12 also contains separate school and child-care device provisions, building on policies announced earlier this year. Those are distinct from the digital-market protections. Neither the bill’s title nor its school rules should obscure the consumer question: whether NB can turn a child’s encounter with a manipulative interface into an enforceable obligation on the company that designed it.

Sources

Related coverage

Comments

Loading comments…